Last week I did a fireside chat with about 75 MSP owners in Tampa.
The folks at Cyberfox were kind enough to invite me to talk about The MSP Playbook, and my friend Joe and I opened up a conversation around some of the frameworks I’ve been working on.
It was the first time I had talked about The MSP Playbook in a room full of MSP owners.
And pretty quickly, the conversation got real.
One question in particular seemed to stop the room for a second.
How do I specialize without killing the business that currently pays my bills?
The MSP owner didn’t ask it exactly that way.
But that’s what I heard.
And I think a lot of MSP owners are wrestling with the same thing.
They can see the promise of a more focused, productized business.
They just don’t see the path from here to there.
So that’s where we’re going.
Because sometimes the problem isn’t believing in the next horizon.
It’s figuring out how to get there.
Hi, I’m Rob.
I write about MSPs, productized services, and why trying to do everything usually creates a harder business instead of a better one.
Field notes and practical playbooks for building a calmer, more focused MSP business.
The fear is rational
You’re staring at $4,000 sitting in front of you and thinking:
“That customer doesn’t really fit our model.”
Of course you take the money.
Especially if your pipeline isn’t predictable.
Especially if your positioning is generic.
Especially if you don’t have enough leads.
Especially if every customer feels precious.
But that’s the loop:
Weak differentiation → weak pipeline → revenue scarcity → take every opportunity → wider service offering → more complexity → weaker differentiation.
And around you go.
What looks like a bad pattern from the outside makes perfect sense from inside the business.
You’re not an Everything MSP because you sat down one day and designed an Everything MSP.
You became one, one opportunity at a time.
Every individual decision probably made sense:
“We can do that.”
“It’s another $2,000 a month.”
“They’re a good client.”
“We don’t want them going somewhere else.”
“We could probably support that.”
Twenty years later, you have 27 tools, twelve service categories, six pricing models, and a sales message that basically says:
We do IT.
And that’s the trap.
The fear of losing revenue keeps you saying yes.
So if saying no feels too risky, I get it.
The question isn’t whether you should suddenly start turning revenue away.
The question is how you begin changing the business without putting the business at risk.
And there’s another force at work here too.
We’re wired to protect what we’ve already invested in.
Years of clients. Revenue. Tools. Processes. People. Habits.
Economists call this the sunk cost fallacy: the tendency to keep going because of what we’ve already invested, even when a different path may now make more sense.
For an MSP owner, that can sound like:
“I’ve spent twenty years building this business. I can’t just walk away from it.”
And you shouldn’t.
The goal isn’t to throw away what you built.
The goal is to figure out which parts belong in the next version of your business.
Before you change your MSP, assess it.
MSPs have been using assessments for years.
Before we recommend a major change to a client, we typically want to understand what they have.
How it’s set up.
What’s working?
What’s not?
Where are the risks?
And where are the opportunities?
An assessment gives us a clearer picture before we make decisions.
So why wouldn’t we do the same thing with our own businesses?
Before you specialize.
Before you change your offer.
Before you try to productize anything.
Actually take a look at what you’ve actually built.
Not what you think you built.
Not what your website says you do.
What’s really there.
That’s what the assessment is for.
And this one is free.
Is this actually the business you want?
At some point, it helps to stop asking:
What can we sell?
And start asking:
What are we trying to build?
What kind of clients do you want more of?
What kind of work do you want to be known for?
What do you want your role to look like?
And what do you want the business to feel like to run?
Those questions matter.
Because the money matters. The product matters. The customer matters. And the delivery model matters.
But so does the person who has to wake up and run the thing every day.
Intentionality before optimization.
First decide what you’re trying to create.
Then make it better.
Don’t overthink this. Run the assessment.
You don’t need to redesign your MSP today.
Start by figuring out what you already have.
I built a short MSP Readiness Assessment to help you look at five areas of your business:
Customer, Product, Economics, Delivery, and Capacity for Change.
Twenty questions. About 10–15 minutes.
At the end, you’ll see where the strongest signals are, what’s getting in the way, and what the evidence suggests you should do next.
This isn’t about scoring your MSP.
It’s about answering a much more useful question:
Is there enough evidence inside the business you have today to start building a better version of it?
Three Ways I Can Help You
1. Subscribe for Weekly Insights — Get clear, practical insights on the MSP business model delivered straight to your inbox.
2. MSP Strategic Advisory — Helping MSP owners simplify their business, sharpen their positioning, and build for the next stage of growth.
3. MSP Ecosystem Advisory — Advisory for vendors, founders, and investors building or investing in the MSP market.
💡 Enjoyed this article? Hit the 🩵 button and drop a comment with your thoughts.
👉 Follow me on LinkedIn for more insights and updates.


